In Derren Brown’s latest book he recommends never using electronics as the main method for mentalism feats. Do you agree with this view?

Given that I am not really a mentalist (although I do like to perform some lightweight mental magic in my shows), and that I have never used any electronic gadgets, I am perhaps not the best person to comment! However, I have always felt that while I have no particular problem with judicious use of electronic methodology in principle, provided that the effects created are strong and believable, I do wonder whether relying exclusively on this type of apparatus is asking for trouble. Reliability of the gimmick is one thing, but there is also the issue of different venues offering potentially poor reception, for example, so that Bluetooth or other signals may struggle to get through. I note in his book that Derren says that he feels you need a low tech back up in case of electronic failures, and that if these alternative methods are also strong, why not just use them anyway and remove the worry! Since the audience should not be made aware of how any of the effects are being achieved, decisions about how much, if any, electronic apparatus to use, should come down to what you, as the performer, consider to be a reasonable risk. Some routines may not be possible by any other methodology, in which case you may decide to take the chance, while with others where there is a choice, you will need to evaluate the pros and cons.