The Difficulty With Knowing How Well You’ve Done

I had an interesting chat with a good magic friend of mine recently in which he told me the tale of a close up gig that he had done which provided him with a big surprise afterwards. He explained that he had done the show and in his view it had gone OK – not the best reactions he’d ever had, but certainly not the worst – and he came away thinking no more about it, almost a case of ‘another one bites the dust’, so to speak.

He exchanged emails afterwards with the booker who said she was pleased with what he had done, so he sent her a link to the booking site where he explained she could leave a review if she so wished. Well, a couple of days later the software informed him that he had a new review, and when he went to read it, he was amazed! The lady was clearly over the moon with him and his magic and was extremely complimentary about all aspects of the magic experience that he had provided! My friend was amazed at how impressed she seemed to be for a show that he had thought was just ‘OK’!

I suppose what this demonstrates is how hard it is for us as performers to accurately judge how good, or otherwise, our shows are. When you have been entertaining the lay public for many years, you will have experienced the huge highs, and occasionally the depressing lows, of audience reactions, so you have a sense of what constitutes a big success in terms of the audience feedback. So, each new performance you tend to compare with the many hundreds, or maybe even thousands, of previous ones.

But the booker may well be assessing your success by a completely different set of values and parameters. If she has not been entertained live by a magician before, her anticipation and expectation may be easily surpassed by what the performer judges to be no more than an OK show, because she has little or no real idea what to expect and so might be easily impressed.

Of course, this can work round the other way too. A booker who is new to magic might build everything up in her head into an occasion that no magician could ever hope to live up to! In which case the booker may be left feeling a little disappointed because the magician did not scale the unreasonable heights she had imagined. This shows that satisfaction on the behalf of the spectators is as much about their expectations of how the show will be as it is about the actual quality of the performance.

Also, an overt demonstration of appreciation from the audience doesn’t automatically mean that everyone present is having the best time. The few noisy people might be, but what about the number of quieter more reflective people present? They might be enjoying it too, and just don’t show any appreciation by their responses, or they might be feeling uncomfortable with the entertainment and not really having fun with it.

If the booker asks the noisy people what they thought, the magician will probably get a glowing report, but if she only happens to question the other group, a very different picture may emerge. And it’s so hard for us to know what’s being said afterwards and therefore what the overriding reaction to the gig is likely to be.

I can remember a close up show I did many years ago through an agent which illustrates this point rather well. I thought the evening was a success – I was certainly getting good reactions to everything I did – but because the number of people present was less than anticipated, the length of time I was contracted to work was too long and so I had really concluded entertaining everyone 20 minutes before my allotted finish time.

So I went to the booker, explained that I had entertained everybody, and asked if he was happy with everything, as if he was, I would like to leave. He assured me that this was fine, thanked me for my show and waved me on my way. A few days later the agent rang me to say the man had lodged a complaint about my going early and was refusing to pay the fee!

Maybe I was naïve, but if he had seemed in any way unhappy with me leaving at the time, I would have entertained some more, even though from a performance point of view the spectators had probably seen enough. But I had no clue as to how he was feeling and so got caught. Which just goes to prove how difficult it is for us performers to know what our spectators are really thinking about our work.