Magic And The AI Invasion

Jack Rhodes is someone who you are almost bound to have heard of. His online video output is excellent and extremely popular, with his YouTube channel having hundreds of thousands of subscribers. In fact, in recent years he has based his growing success and profile on his ability to produce a never-ending stream of innovative magic-based online content.

Given all this, it might be seen as a possible ‘own goal’ when he produced an extremely entertaining yet well argued video lecture in which he claims that AI has now made almost anything seen on screen as potentially fake, which for those seeking to perform magic using the medium (such as him!) removes all credibility.

Magic has always had a potential problem with being filmed because even if AI faking is not being used, selective filming angles and shots can create impossible looking magic that a lay person can easily dismiss as ‘camera tricks’.

When performing close up, where conversation with the audience is often possible, I have been told that my magic is amazing because it was performed live, right under their noses, which they find so much better than magic on TV which they can’t trust. The audiences feel they can look where they want to and not just what the TV director opts to show them.

The conclusion and solution that Jack comes to in his video talk is that performing live is the best antidote to filmed magic, and that when the current craze for online magic fades away because it is too unbelievable, magicians will find themselves perhaps back in big demand for live performances.

Actually, I would suggest that this has always been the case, the only difference being that unlike in the past, there is now an avalanche of magic on You Tube which COVID originally inspired as a replacement for face to face performances and which has dominated the hearts and minds of many magicians as they become intent on chasing maximum viewing figures for their work.

So I suppose the wider question is – does screen magic have any purpose or validity anymore? As a medium for providing the general public with entertaining footage involving magic, I would suggest it does. Like with the CGI used in films as mentioned above, lay people will enjoy amusing, wacky, innovative content if the obvious purpose of the content is not to fool but simply to entertain.

A more traditional magic show which relies primarily on presenting illusions that seek to puzzle, may not work in the future, unless perhaps it is a streaming of a live event. For decades TV magicians have sought to reassure their viewers that everything they are watching is kosher by having a live audience present, and if the show is being aired in actual time rather than being recorded for later screening, it might prevent the accusations of digital tampering.

The other way that magic on screen will continue to work is for presenting performances or lectures aimed entirely at magicians. Since a lecture contains magic that is then explained, the performer can’t enhance it digitally, and indeed there would be no point in doing so. I have always maintained that Zoom lectures are an excellent format to learn from, and I see no reason for this to change in the foreseeable future.

For well over 100 years magic has had to adapt to changes brought on by technology, and this is simply the latest example of how modern day science is having an impact on our art. We have always been quick to adopt new ideas and to harness them for our own ends, and indeed the online content of Jack Rhodes and others shows what can be achieved, so it will be fascinating to see how magic morphs itself again in the face of the AI invasion.