
I subscribe to a twice weekly published email newsletter called One Ahead, which features all manner of articles written by a number of magically knowledgeable writers, and I usually find it to be a stimulating read. A recent edition, written by Giacomo Bigliardi, was devoted to discussing Ben Hart’s latest commercial show called Ben Hart : Up Close.
Unlike Ben’s stage shows, this latest close up offering will only be presented at the Adelaide Fringe since the format of the show is not financially viable as a touring option. Ben’s quoted purpose of producing this type of intimate show is so that he can interact more effectively with the audience, which might lead you to imagine he will be presenting performances for small numbers of spectators at a time.
However, that’s not the case, as the room he will be performing in accommodates 200, but arranged as only two rows of 100 seats in a circle right around the performing space. One imagines that with 100 chairs to fit into each circle, the spectators will not exactly be right on top of Ben as he performs, but it does mean that half the audience will have a front row seat while the other half will only have one person in front of them.
This interesting topological arrangement of seating attempts to give quite a large number of people the best view, while at the same time making the spectators themselves feel close to the action and available for Ben to involve in the magic.
Of course, because he is surrounded, presumably table top close up effects will not be possible, and for visibility reasons the props he uses will have to be of a reasonable size, thus cutting out a large number of traditional close up tricks. In fact, Ben says that he will be using some of the effects from his stage shows, which then begs the question, is this really a close up show?
I have long argued that the way magicians classify tricks and break them into groups (close up, stand up etc), is really more as a means to catalogue and categorise certain types of effect than it is as a way of designating exactly what tricks should be used where.
Close up magic surely, simply implies that the magician will be working close to his audience, not what effects he is supposed to have in his act. So, if the performer chooses to do a dove production and can manage it successfully with his audience sitting up close, then it doesn’t matter that this type of magic is not normally associated with close up.
Back in 1988 I entered the FISM close up competition in The Netherlands. The winner that year was Johnny Ace Palmer whose close up act comprised mainly of stage type effects. At the time, he really stood out compared to everyone else who was doing cards and coins, and in fact he not only won the close up, but was crowned as overall FISM Champion where he was in competition with all eight of the performance categories.
Johnny had demonstrated that close up may be a magic category, but should not be a defining limitation on the material that is performed, and Ben Hart is doing the same with his Fringe show. So, the lesson to be learned for all of us, perhaps, is choose magic that works in the performing circumstances, not simply that fits an artificial categorisation.
