
How do you judge whether a trick has been enjoyed and appreciated by an audience? After all, under most performing situations you don’t get the chance to sit down with your spectators for a detailed debrief, and so you have to rely on other visible or audible signs that indicate approval.
Obviously, the traditional way that an audience shows its pleasure (or otherwise!) at your performance is by applause. However, receiving a clap at the end of a trick does not necessarily accurately reflect whether the audience genuinely liked what you did, because applause can simply be an automatic response to the conclusion of a trick or act, something which social convention almost requires of the spectators, irrespective of how they rated the performance.
Now, applause can be a barometer of success, depending on its intensity. I’m sure that most of us have been at some point in our lives watching a performance that has left us seriously underwhelmed, and at the end the performer receives the dreaded ‘polite applause’, where the audience does put their hands together but not with much enthusiasm or vigour.
On the other hand, an act that is truly outstanding will get a much stronger ovation at its conclusion, where the noise generated is louder, where it may be supplemented by shouts or whoops of excited reaction, where the spectators raise their hands higher as they applaud, or where people jump to their feet. A standing ovation is generally considered to be the ultimate way for an audience to express their delight, even though at times it seems to me that these days such clamour is too easily and too often awarded to people who are good but not truly remarkable.
So you might imagine that the best way to gauge whether you have been a success or not is simply to listen to the applause, but I would suggest that this is not a reliable enough way to assess your success. For instance, commercial close up magicians often work in situations that don’t encourage applause. Performing at a table of two people in a quiet restaurant is unlikely to create any clapping because, unlike in a theatre, for instance, it is not a situation in which people expect to applaud. The spectators may make positive comments quietly to you, and that may be all, but this doesn’t mean you’ve not been a huge success for them.
Magic is also fairly unique in the entertainment world in that a performance seeks to fool and confuse the audience, not just give them pleasure. This can lead to a muted response at the immediate conclusion to a trick because the spectators’ brains are occupied with trying to take in, understand and probably fathom out exactly what they have just seen. Some people can literally be stunned by a strong trick, and so their lack of overt reaction should not be interpreted as a failure on your part.
Bearing all this in mind, it’s probably true to say that the person least likely to genuinely understand how well they have done is often going to be the performer himself. Much better is to get the feedback afterwards of someone who you know and trust, who has been in the audience, and who has heard first hand the comments that spectators made amongst themselves after the show.
Failing that, try filming your performance each time and watch it afterwards dispassionately, as this will not only allow you to critique your performance from a technical standpoint, but the video will also capture the applause levels and possibly some spectator comments too.
