I think it depends on what you mean by ‘complex’. If a trick involves a huge amount of convoluted handling and process in order to eventually arrive at a magical conclusion, the danger is that in most performing situations the spectators are likely to switch off and cease to care. However, an effect which is intriguingly multi-layered, (some mental routines fall into this category) can work really well because it is the complexity of the plot which lends the trick its power and impact. There is therefore a big difference between a trick which consists of endless dealing of cards into piles for no apparent reason, and one in which several different elements are brought together and turn out to have been predicted in advance. The first is complex but it doesn’t make much sense (other than to achieve the method), the second is making a feature of the fact that so many diverse things can appear to have been foreseen. The performing situation also plays a big part. If you are working close up in a busy environment where there are a lot of distractions diverting the attention of the spectators, simple plot lines are more effective. An intimate performance for a select group in a quiet environment can release you to try more complex effects, as it is easier to manage the spectators’ attention.
