Where do you stand on the ‘Too Perfect Theory’? I can’t see why magicians would want to do tricks that aren’t as amazing as possible!

Interesting question. It tends to be mentalists who worry that some of their effects can seem too impossible to be ‘believable’, but I wonder whether this is more of a problem for the performers themselves than it is for the watching public. Lay people generally have little or no idea how we achieve most of what we do, so to them just about everything seems impossible! They assume that every trick we perform we will achieve with a 100% success rate, and so to present a routine in which you get close to the perfect result, but not quite, seems to me to be disappointing the audience’s expectations. So I don’t quite understand why mentalists think it’s better to guess the change in a spectator’s pocket as £3.76, when in reality it is £3.85. It doesn’t really make it any more believable to the audience, because they know it’s all a ‘trick’ anyway, and so to get the amount slightly wrong just makes it look like you missed. It would be like a magician performing a four coin matrix and failing to get the final coin to join the others, working on the theory that to have all four arrive would be just ‘too perfect’. If as a mindreader you think that people genuinely believe you can read minds, I would suggest you need a reality check. Most lay people may not be able to explain what you do, but most don’t believe it’s real. So for them, the ‘Too Perfect Theory’ is never a consideration.