Which is best for learning magic – books or DVDs?

Both have advantages and disadvantages. A well written book can offer a lot of depth and discussion about a topic and if augmented by good illustrations is a fine way to learn how to perform magic. A book is also easy to browse and provides a quick way to access specific information without the need to resort to any sort of electrical equipment! Older magicians were brought up on learning from books and so usually have no problems in transferring the detail on the page to actions. Video and DVD have caused a sea change in how we now learn magic. The vast majority of tricks now come with some sort of video instruction, and often that is all that is provided. The benefits of being able to see exactly what the effect and handling is supposed to be are obvious, and if done well, a DVD can offer good illustrations of misdirection and timing, something that a book can struggle with. So, I think both have value. I prefer books on the whole as they are usually a nicer physical object, but DVD can play a vital role for teaching longer or more complex routines.