Over the last 15-20 years mentalism has become much more mainstream as a form of entertainment for the general public, a trend that has arguably been created in the UK by the success of Derren Brown. When it is well presented, there is no doubt that mental effects can appear particularly unfathomable and often appear to delve into the personal lives of the spectators, something which can leave a significant impression. I also think that lay people can less easily come up with their own simplistic explanations for what a mentalist performs – the old chestnuts of ‘it’s up your sleeve’ or ‘it’s all done by mirrors’ etc, just aren’t relevant or appropriate when trying to understand mentalism, which again makes it all seem more impressive. Having said all that, I do think that good, strong magic, presented well, can be hugely enjoyable and satisfying to a lay audience. The number of plot variations and presentational possibilities make standard magic more versatile, in my opinion, and in certain performing situations, such as with table hopping or strolling gigs, magic is much easier to use effectively and fits more readily with the need to get into and out of a group quickly while still leaving a strong impression.
