Does it matter that my act is full of standard dealer items? I keep reading articles saying that we should all be individual and creative, but I like the tricks I do even though to magicians they are old hat.

Just because a trick is standard in the eyes of magicians does not necessarily mean that you shouldn’t use it to entertain lay people. Don’t forget that most audiences are made up of people who rarely if ever get to see a magic show, and so as long as you present your tricks in an entertaining way that pleases your spectators, there’s no real reason to worry. For instance, there are some close up magicians who look down on those who use the sponge balls or the Professor’s Nightmare in their shows, but that is nonsense, since both these are still hugely relevant and suitable for lay people if performed well. Magicians are a little obsessed with the ‘latest’ or ‘what’s new’, but the fact of the matter is that there are already more than enough truly great magic tricks in existence to supply every magician in the world with material for their acts for ever more, so having something cutting edge is not really the issue. If your act is well put together and you are getting success with classic or standard tricks, then I see nothing wrong with that at all.