Normally the mistake that people make when first trying to classic palm a coin is that they squeeze their palm in too tightly around the coin with the result that their fingers stick straight out stiffly and sometimes their thumb will stick up like they are trying to thumb a lift! So, I would recommend the following. First, make sure you are using a large enough coin. A half dollar is great, or a £2 coin perhaps, but anything smaller will mean you have to fold your palm in far more to grip the coin edges and that then creates the unnatural look you are trying to avoid. Second, try to relax the grip so that it is enough to keep the coin in place but does not use any extra pressure. Third, train your fingers to curl inwards towards your palm in a more natural posture rather than sticking out straight. Finally, make your thumb go ‘looser’ so that it lies more naturally along the line of your hand rather than sticking out. When palming the coin, also practise picking objects up with the coin still palmed in the same hand – you need to still be able to use the hand while concealing the coin.
