Magic has always been considered as a ‘special case’ when it comes to refunds. The law in the UK dictates that customers are entitled to request their money back or an exchange if a product is supplied defective or damaged, and all magic dealers should at the very least be offering this to their customers. But the wider problem that magic has is that often the core element of what is being sold is an idea, sometimes with little or no extra props. So, if a customer is in any way dishonest, they could buy routines, learn them or copy the instructions, and then say they didn’t like them and send them back for a refund. Usually dealers who offer an unequivocal guarantee such as the one that you mention are selling products for which you need the supplied props. These bits of apparatus will usually be almost impossible to copy (made from metal, brass, wood, leather etc) and so the accompanying idea that is sold with them is useless on its own. This means that if someone wants to return it for a refund, they can’t do so dishonestly. The other refund issue these days is caused by online video instructions. When you purchase a product you get a url to download the video. Once you have that, you can’t expect a refund on something that you have already downloaded to keep.
