Yes, occasionally I have had a spectator try to call the shots about where a card is returned. The trouble is, with most tricks it probably doesn’t matter where the card is put in the deck, but usually we intend to control the card after it has been replaced, so you can’t just hand over the deck and invite the spectator to reinsert the card wherever they like. You certainly don’t want to get into an argument over it, so I always try to make light of it by making a bit of a joke out of it. I’ll say something like, “Sorry, no, because I can’t do the trick otherwise!” or, “Look, this trick’s difficult enough as it is, thank you.” Normally the spectator will be holding the card out at fingertips when they try this approach, so I quickly grab the card off them and lose it in the deck as I make one of the above remarks, and I think if you punctuate this with a grin, most spectators will just laugh. You certainly don’t want to get into a tug-of-war with the card! One approach, if you haven’t been able to get the card back, is to hand the deck over anyway and let the spectator lose it in the deck. You then replace the deck in the box which you put away in your pocket. You then bring out some rope and do a rope trick. By the time that they realise that you didn’t continue with the card trick, you will have moved on to the next table.
