This probably depends on what sort of performer you wish to be regarded as. For some people, it is important that they are seen as a mindreader only, and if this is the case, suddenly breaking away from mental effects in order to perform a torn and restored newspaper just wouldn’t be correct. For the last few years in particular, there has been a strong trend towards mentalism for lay people (fuelled originally by Derren Brown’s success in the UK), and magic itself seems to have been looked down upon in some circles and perceived as being less current or bookable. So a lot of performers have sought to distance themselves from being seen as magicians and have concentrated instead on presenting exclusively mentalism. Clearly these performers would need to avoid doing anything that smacked of general magic. However, personally I have never had a problem with mixing a bit of mindreading/mentalism with my other regular stuff as I feel that it broadens my appeal to the lay audience and provides a variety of material that I feel is more interesting.
