
I was reading a fascinating article by Rory Adams in his book Magic For The Rest Of Us recently in which he was discussing the use of stooges in magic. I don’t think I’ve ever come across such an in depth appraisal of the subject before, and the many ways that he had thought to analyse the use of this magical ‘dark art’ was really thought provoking.
Having read the piece I was left with one main overriding question in my mind – is it EVER acceptable to use a stooge? Or is the idea of having a secret assistant mixed in with the audience a step too far?
If you think logically about it for a moment, you can argue that for a lay audience the effect is everything and the method, which by rights should remain a secret at all times, is immaterial. So if the strongest trick can be achieved by means of a confederate, provided that the audience does not in any way suspect that this is a possibility, surely it’s fair game, isn’t it?
As magicians we often have an ambivalent attitude to methods. We laud those who use extreme sleight of hand skill to achieve magic, and look down on those who entertain using simple or even self working methods. Yet often it’s true that the magic achieved easily, if presented correctly, can be every bit as impressive and enjoyable to a lay audience as the difficult stuff, and sometimes even more so.
It’s this same attitude that results in many performers seeing the use of stooges as ‘cheating’, as if this particular method is unworthy of a proper magician. But surely it’s no more ‘cheating’ than using a gaffed deck or a gimmicked coin, is it? A secret assistant is also really no different from the girl who jumps into an onstage illusion box and who basically makes the magic work while the performer himself does very little to actually make the magic happen. We don’t consider that the illusionist is cheating, do we?
In Rory’s article, he suggested that it might depend on who was using the stooge as to whether it was acceptable or not. A hobbyist magician going down that route in order to fool friends and family was OK, or as a means of throwing an audience of magicians off the scent perhaps. But for serious professionals, such as major TV stars or top end performers, he felt it was unadvisable even though there are those in that field who do use such techniques.
Then you have to consider how a stooge is being used. You can position a friend or colleague in the lay audience and pretend to select them at random for a routine, but you have to make sure that the actual selection process appears unequivocally fair and above board to avoid suspicion.
Alternatively you can use pre-show to turn an audience member into an effective stooge by having them make choices or decisions ahead of time that are more controlled than the showtime presentation will make it appear. Good use of dual reality can help with this.
Or you can create instant stooges during the show where you secretly get helpers from the audience to ‘play along’ with what you need. A risky but often used strategy.
The bottom line surely, is that you mustn’t get caught using a stooge, and if you achieve that, it’s a strong methodology.
