The Danger Of Claiming Genuine Powers

With the exception of most young children, nobody really believes that magicians have genuine powers that enable them to do the amazing feats that they present. All rational adults understand that although they don’t know how most of the tricks they witness are done, they usually accept that there is a method, a logical secret, behind it all.

In a similar way, no sane person believes that a ventriloquist’s dummy can really speak unaided, the audience just play along with the idea and enjoy the fact that the ventriloquist is skilfully throwing his voice to create the illusion that the doll can talk.

So, given these unquestionable truths, why is it that some of these same people are happy to believe that there are mentalists who can genuinely read people’s minds? And what is it about psychics that can convince some gullible souls that they have genuine powers which enables them to contact the dead or tell someone’s fortune?

On one level it’s probably to do with the depth of impossibility that is created by the performer. Many magic effects fool spectators, but because they have already accepted that all magic essentially has a secret, they don’t attribute the illusion as being anything more than a ‘trick’.

But if a mentalist appears to reveal some personal facts about a spectator’s life, the totally inexplicable nature of how he came by the information is so far out of the realms of the average person’s understanding and knowledge, that the only way they can imagine it is possible is if the performer has genuine powers.

As a result of this attitude, some mentalists seek to play on this belief system. Even if they fall short of openly stating that they can genuinely read minds, the manner of their performance and style of presentation constantly reinforces the idea that what the audience is witnessing is a real exhibition of mental powers.

All this is fine up to a point, but with this type of power comes a certain responsibility. Fake mediums who extract money from people who desperately want to contact deceased relatives, are using their skills in a morally redundant way. It goes beyond honest deception and becomes something far more damaging.

Similarly, mentalists who claim to be able to predict the future with demonstrable certainty, can open themselves up to criticism. For instance, let’s imagine a performer is doing a Newspaper Headline Prediction, in which he claims to know well in advance what a headline news item will be. If on the day the headline is about a local murder, not only is the subject matter not entertaining, but believers might rightly question why, if the performer knew what the headline was going to be, he didn’t do something to stop the event happening!

As performers we know and understand that it’s basically a trick, but for those people who want to believe that the mentalist is genuine, his apparent lack of a moral compass could be upsetting.

The fact is, there’s probably little to be gained from pretending you have any type of otherworldly powers. After all, if you were a genuine magician who could literally make anything happen by sorcery, would you waste your time with card tricks? I don’t think so!